In Between · The Gaygency
v4 · May 1, 2026
Pitch Strategy v4 · Client-Aligned

Two angles.
One specific story.
Twenty-one days.

The strategy in one breath: two angles, each rooted in a specific moment that makes this film unforgettable. The shame of being a secret. The actor who wrote himself the role. Press pickup and audience awareness move as one push, not two.

Primary angles
2
Wave 1 outlets
8 names
First placement
OUT · May 12
Monthly review
May 19

00 What changed in v4

v3 was validated. Two surgical edits and a stack of operational confirms. Nothing else moved.

Edit 1 · Cut Primary 03

"First husky gay leading man in 26 years" is out. Elle and Cameron both flagged "Things Like This" as a recent comp that breaks the claim. Body politics still rides underneath Primary 02 ("wasn't being cast in love stories"). We don't talk down peer films anywhere, privately or publicly.

Edit 2 · Reframe Krystal/Broadway

Merrily already aired on Netflix. The angle was "her other 2026 premiere is coming." It's now retrospective: "fresh off Merrily, Krystal's next move is producing the queer indie Hollywood wasn't going to greenlight." Holds for a Krystal-led press wave once stills are in hand.

Operational confirms

  • OUT (Equal Pride) interview locked: Sachin + Aaron, Tue May 12, 1pm PT
  • Landing page: Krystal + Christian own it, ships Mon May 4 EOD
  • Media content: Cam + Nick + Elle producing, uploads to Drive
  • Most v3 open questions answered (see Section 08)

How to read this deck

  1. The 2 primary angles. Each one says what the pitch actually is in one breath, why it works, the lead spokesperson, and the audience hook + press hook. These are what we lead with.
  2. The 3 supporting angles. When and how to deploy them. Not in Wave 1.
  3. The narrative hierarchy. The three-layer model every pitch, every email, every ad has to honor. Top layer first, bottom layer last. Always in this order.
  4. The messaging guidance. What to lead with. What to avoid. Tone rules. Print this.
  5. The 21-day execution plan. Three waves, the 8 Wave 1 names, what we deprioritize and why, and what "done" looks like at the May 19 monthly review.
  6. The eight publishable headlines. Each passes the "would I click on this" test before it tries to teach you anything.
  7. Spokesperson routing + remaining open questions. Five locked spokespeople and the three answers still pending.
  8. Appendix. The full 4-tier outlet map (152 targets) and the angles we considered or set aside, including the canon-gap angle now retired in v4.

01 The Two Primary Angles

Two strong primaries beats three with a soft one. Each is romcom-first, tied to Nicholas's lived experience, and works for both press pickup and audience awareness.

01
Primary · The Emotional Spine

"He got the dream. The dream made him a secret."

The husky gay protagonist finally gets the British boyfriend he's been told to want, and the boyfriend hides him in public. The whole movie becomes about whether you can keep loving someone who only loves you with the lights off, and whether the answer changes anything about how you see yourself.

Why it works
  • Specific. The British boyfriend. The secret. Specificity is what gets shared.
  • Universally recognizable. Every queer person who's been told "I love you, but not in front of my family" knows this.
  • Hooks audiences and writers with the same line. Critics don't have to translate.
  • Avoids the therapy-speak trap of "self-love journey" framing while delivering the same emotional payload.
Lead voice
Nicholas Molencupp + Cameron Moir paired. The dynamic between Nick and Beau IS the angle, so both actors carry it.
Audience hook
"Have you ever been someone's secret?" One-line social caption. People who've felt this will tag a friend on sight.
Press hook
A one-line setup that carries the entire emotional weight of the film. The review writes itself around the reader's recognition of the line.
02
Primary · Lived Experience

"He wasn't being cast in love stories. So he wrote one."

Nicholas wrote himself a romcom because nobody was going to write one for him. That sentence is the entire film's origin in eight words. It carries the lived experience, the body politics, the indie-craft story, and the emotional spine in one line.

Why it works
  • The most emotionally compelling line in the whole pitch set. We had this buried in supporting; it belongs at the front.
  • Profile-shaped, not review-shaped. Gives a journalist scaffolding for a feature about Nicholas as an artist, with the film as the proof.
  • Profiles travel further than reviews. They get reposted, screenshot, quoted on socials.
  • Audience permission-structure: people want to root for someone who refused to wait. That's a fanbase, not a viewership.
Lead voice
Nicholas Molencupp solo · this story belongs in his mouth
Audience hook
"He didn't wait for permission." People want to be in on a story like that early.
Press hook
A profile lede that gives journalists the human-interest scaffolding to write a feature, not just a review.

02 Supporting Angles

Not in Wave 1. Each one has a specific moment to be deployed. Until that moment, it stays in the drawer.

S1
Supporting · Theater Crossover · Reframed v4

The post-Merrily Krystal Joy Brown angle

Merrily already aired on Netflix. New framing, retrospective: fresh off the live capture, Krystal's next move is producing the queer indie nobody in the studio system was going to greenlight. It's "what does she do next," not "her other premiere is coming."

Use when
Anytime, but it gets sharpest once we have stills and a teaser. Best fit: late May / June theater press wave once Krystal is cleared for press hits.
How to deploy
Playbill, BroadwayWorld, TheaterMania, NewYorkTheater.me, plus Variety theater (Gordon Cox) and THR theater (David Rooney) for the cross-pollinated culture reads.
Sample lede
"Fresh off her Merrily We Roll Along live capture, Krystal Joy Brown isn't taking the easy lane. Her next move is producing the queer indie romcom Hollywood wasn't going to greenlight."
Voice
Krystal Joy Brown lead
S2
Supporting · Mental Health · Conditional on Trevor

"A romcom that takes mental health seriously"

In Between treats Nick's interior life as the movie itself, not as the movie's topic. The right activation for this angle is a real partnership behind it.

Use when
Trevor Project partnership is confirmed. NOT before.
How to deploy
Once a partnership is signed, this becomes the actionable companion angle to Primary 01. Adds a tangible "and here's what we're doing about it" beat to the press push.
Voice
Nicholas Molencupp
Until then
We mention mental health honestly when it surfaces in interviews tied to Primary 01. We don't pitch it as a standalone angle. We hold it for when we have something to actually offer.
S3
Supporting · Made By People · Industry-Trade Only

The "made by people, on purpose" angle

The Indiegogo, leafleted-gay-bars, equity-from-community, refused-to-AI-anything origin story. Don't lead with it. It's the answer to the "why does this movie even exist" question every long profile eventually asks.

Use when
Indie-craft outlets ask the "how did this get made" question. Filmmaker Magazine, Hammer to Nail, MovieMaker, IndieWire industry desk.
How to deploy
Drop it as the second beat in any conversation about the film's making. Pairs with Primary 02.
Voice
Elle Army + Cameron Moir

03 Narrative Hierarchy

The three-layer model every pitch, every email, every sponsored ad has to honor. Top layer first, bottom layer last. Always in this order.

1 Core story
What the film is

A husky gay man chases the British Adonis he's been told to want, gets him, finds out he's a secret, and has to figure out whether he can love himself enough to walk away. It's a romcom. It's funny. It's specific. The British accent is real. The chase is real. The heartbreak is real. The friends are funny.

2 Emotional layer
Why it matters

The cruelest voice in the room is the one in your own head. Most love stories blame the world; this one points the camera at the protagonist and says: what would change if you stopped agreeing with the people who reject you. The love story is between Nick and Nick. Beau is the catalyst, not the prize.

3 Movement layer
Why it exists now

A husky gay actor stopped waiting for somebody to write him a love story, and made his own. Hollywood has been telling a generation of queer men that their interior life is a punchline and their love life is somebody else's. In Between hands the leading-man slot back. Built grassroots, on purpose, with community money, because a story like this was never going to come down through the studio system. We don't lead with the canon-gap claim, but the body politics is still here for any writer who reaches for it.

The order rule Lead with the romcom. Let the emotional layer land underneath. Let the movement layer reveal itself only when the writer asks for it. Never invert. Even in interviews.

04 Key Messaging Guidance

Print this. Tape it to the wall before you write a pitch email or an ad caption.

Lead with

  • The romcom. The British boyfriend. The chase. The comedy. The friends. The specifics.
  • Nicholas's voice. He wrote it from his life. That's the credibility currency.
  • Specificity over generality. "Husky gay man" beats "diverse representation." "British Adonis who treats him as a secret" beats "love interest with internalized homophobia."
  • A line a reader can repeat at a dinner party. Sharable beats correct.
  • Romcom craft language. "Inversion." "Antagonist is the protagonist." "First-act kiss." This signals you take the genre seriously.

Avoid

  • "Important." "Much-needed." "Powerful." "Necessary." Any word an indie filmmaker uses when they don't trust their own movie.
  • "Body positivity" as a noun. The film is body-affirming. It is not a body positivity movie.
  • "Mental health" as a category label. Nick's interior life is the movie, not its topic.
  • Coming-out language. This is a coming-home-to-yourself story.
  • Any framing that suggests homework. "Should be required viewing" is a sentence we never write or invite.
  • Trend-chasing language. Anything that sounds like it's chasing the news cycle (AI, the administration, TikTok) gets cut.
  • "Diverse cast." We earn that descriptor. We don't lead with it.
  • Any claim about being "the first" husky gay leading man, in any number of years. Cut.
  • Any framing that talks down "Things Like This" or any peer film. We differentiate by what In Between is, not by what other films aren't.
  • The word "actually." Em dashes. Emojis. Banned everywhere.

Tone & framing

  • Funny first. Sad second. Profound only by accident.
  • Warm, not earnest. Earnest pitches read as defensive. Warmth reads as confident.
  • Specific, not universal. Nick's story being his is what makes it everyone's.
  • Confident, not pleading. We don't ask for coverage. We tell writers what we're doing and why they'd want in.
  • Conversational, not corporate. We sound like a friend with taste, not a marketing department.
  • Romcom-first, theme-second, always.

05 21-Day Execution Plan

Two primaries, three waves, eight Wave 1 names. Press push and audience awareness as one operation. OUT (Equal Pride) already landed via Cameron's warm path — runs May 12.

Wave 1
Days 1–7 · May 1 to May 7

The 8 we send first

Primary 01 + 02 only. No supporting angles yet.

  1. Murtada Elfadl · NewFest Senior Programmer + Variety film critic. One pitch, two surfaces.
  2. Aidan Wharton · Gay Buffet Substack. Was in Fire Island AND Bros. Warmest cultural intro.
  3. The Yearning · Brooklyn queer Substack, NewFest community partner.
  4. Drew Burnett Gregory · freelance, sets queer Twitter TIFF agenda. Long-form essay channel.
  5. Coleman Spilde · Salon + Top Shelf Low Brow. Brooklyn-based, gay-canon-literate.
  6. Pat Mullen · POV Magazine + Xtra. Owns the Inside Out preview cycle.
  7. Chris Azzopardi · Q Syndicate. Single pitch wires to every regional LGBTQ paper.
  8. Hammer to Nail · Don R. Lewis. Indie-craft outlet for Primary 02 + Supporting S3.
Wave 2
Days 8–17 · May 8 to May 17

Build off the OUT placement

Push a "we're in OUT, here's what's next" angle with 6 to 7 more outlets once the interview airs (or once we have a publication date). Begin warm-DM grassroots Tier 1 contacts in parallel: Hunter Harris (Hung Up), Joe Reid + Chris Feil, W42ST Hell's Kitchen, Hell Gate, Brooklyn Paper, Greenpointers, GO Magazine. Open Supporting S1 (post-Merrily Krystal angle) with theater press if Krystal is cleared for press hits.

Wave 3
Days 18–21 · May 18 to May 19

Hold headroom + lock the report

Hold 3 emails of headroom for late requests. Activate NewFest community partners (The Yearning, Hell Gate, W42ST) once NewFest38 dates are public. Lock the renewal vs. non-renewal recommendation for the May 19 monthly report.

Audience awareness · the same push, not a parallel one

  • Landing page goes live Mon May 4 EOD. Krystal + Christian own the build (out of scope per SOW §2.5). Single email signup. "Become an in-betweener." That phrase is the only call-to-action verb on the page.
  • Meta paid ads launch by Day 7 (May 4 if partner access lands in time, otherwise the day after access is granted). Two creative variants built around Primary 01 and Primary 02: the romcom and lived-experience hooks, not the representation hook (Meta is risk-averse on body language). $500/mo floor.
  • Media content ownership. Cameron, Nick, and Elle producing ads + social creative. Uploads to 02_Assets/ in the Drive as deliverables land.
  • Every press placement gets pushed to the email list within 24 hours. Press → email list → social → more email signups. The list is the asset that survives the festival circuit.
  • Cast social activation in lockstep with the OUT publication date. Julian Burzynski (3M TikTok), Aaron Goldenberg (1.1M TikTok), Sachin Bhatt: coordinated post on the day OUT publishes, driving traffic to the email list.
What we deprioritize and why
  • All Tier 4 major trades for the May window. Variety, Deadline, THR, IndieWire chief desk: they don't pick up a pre-festival "we exist" pitch. Hold for the Aug to Oct festival run wave when there's news.
  • The canon-gap claim entirely. "Things Like This" exists as a recent comp; the "first in 26 years" framing doesn't survive a fact-check. Body politics still rides underneath Primary 02.
  • Krystal / Broadway angle until late May or June. Reframed retrospectively (post-Merrily). Hold until Krystal is cleared for press hits and we have stills.
  • Anti-AI angle. Trend-chasing. Cut.
  • Political "Romance As Resistance" angle. Manufactured. Cut.
  • TikTok-cast angle. Trend-chasing and dilutes the romcom positioning. Cut.
  • Trevor Project / mental health pitch. Hold until partnership is signed. Don't promise what we don't have.
  • Atlanta press. Useful but regional. Run as a parallel low-effort lane, not in the main wave.
  • Tier 1 student arts press (NYU, Columbia). Out of session for the May window. Reactivate in late August.

What "done" looks like at Day 21 (May 19 monthly review)

  • OUT (Equal Pride) interview filmed and scheduled to publish
  • 3 to 5 additional placements in queer/indie press (Tier 1 + Tier 2)
  • 1 syndicated pickup via Q Syndicate (regional LGBTQ papers)
  • Email list at 500+ subscribers
  • Meta campaign in delivery, 100K+ impressions on US/CA queer + indie-film audiences
  • Trevor Project conversation initiated (regardless of outcome, initiated)
  • Krystal post-Merrily angle teed up for a June theater-press wave

06 Eight Publishable Headlines

Each one passes the "would I click on this" test before it tries to teach you anything.

1
"He Got the Dream. The Dream Made Him a Secret."
Primary 01 · the lede · sharable verbatim
2
"The Romcom About the Boyfriend Who Hides You"
Primary 01 alternate · Vulture, The Cut, GQ
3
"He Wasn't Being Cast in Love Stories. So He Wrote One."
Primary 02 · the profile lede · features and indie outlets
4
"The Husky Gay Actor Who Wrote Himself the Boyfriend"
Primary 02 sharpest version · Out, them., Advocate
5
"What If the Person Refusing to Love You Was the One You Loved?"
Primary 01 long-form · Bright Wall/Dark Room, Reverse Shot, Substack
6
"The Gay Romcom Where the Love Interest Is the Cruelty"
Primary 01 craft version · film critics
7
"After Merrily, Krystal Joy Brown Is Producing the Queer Indie Hollywood Wouldn't Greenlight"
Supporting S1 (post-Merrily) · theater + culture press
8
"Wrote Himself a Love Story. Filmed It With People."
Primary 02 + Supporting S3 fused · indie-craft outlets

07 Spokesperson Routing

Five locked spokespeople. Each angle has a recommended lead. We don't route press to anyone outside this list.

Nicholas Molencupp
Writer / Director / Lead
  • Primary 01 (paired with Cameron)
  • Primary 02 (lead, solo: this story belongs in his mouth)
  • Supporting S2 (mental health, conditional on Trevor)
Krystal Joy Brown
Executive Producer
  • Supporting S1 (post-Merrily retrospective, lead)
Cameron Moir
Producer / Actor (Beau)
  • Primary 01 (paired with Nicholas: the Nick/Beau dynamic IS the angle)
  • Supporting S3 (made by people, on purpose)
Elle Army
Producer / Actor
  • Supporting S3 (made by people, on purpose, lead)
  • Producer-side voice on industry-trade conversations
Jay Manuel
Senior Executive Producer
  • Hold for Tier 4 name-recognition outlets only: Variety, THR, Deadline, Out
  • Best for awards-cycle and broader-reach pickups, not the May 8 wave

08 What's still open

Most v3 questions answered (logged below). Three answers still pending before the next milestones.

Trevor Project — any forward motion since the kickoff call? If a conversation has opened, we can pre-stage Supporting S2 for a June drop.
Lead-line approval — is "He got the dream. The dream made him a secret." a line Nicholas is comfortable having quoted in his name in a review or feature?
Krystal availability for late May / June theater press — once stills are in hand, is Krystal cleared for Broadway-press hits, or do we hold Supporting S1 for the festival run?

v3 questions now answered (logged)

  • Lock primary angles · Cut "first husky gay leading man in 26 years" (Things Like This exists). Reframe Krystal/Broadway from "her other 2026 premiere is coming" to retrospective post-Merrily. Source: Elle, 2026-04-30.
  • Landing page · Krystal + Christian DeMarais building. Live by Mon May 4 EOD. Out of scope per SOW §2.5 — we provide structural guidance, not the build. Source: KJB + Daniel, 2026-04-30.
  • Cast social activation · Cam, Nick, Elle producing media content for ads + social. Uploads to 02_Assets/ in the Drive as ready. Source: Elle, 2026-04-30.
  • Anything to pull or soften · Two angle changes above. Roadmap and strategy otherwise approved ("the roadmap is amazing"). Source: Elle, 2026-04-30.
  • First pitch placement · OUT (Equal Pride). Sachin + Aaron, Tue May 12, 1pm PT. Source: Cameron + Daniel + Ricky, 2026-04-30 to 2026-05-01.
  • OUT — push for Nick or hold? · Make them fans on this round, capitalize off the conversation for the next wave. Don't push Nick on this placement. Source: Krystal, 2026-04-30.

Once the three remaining questions land, we refine the 2 lead angles into one-page pitches with headline + opening paragraph, build the Wave 1 outreach list (8 emails inside SOW caps), draft talking points for Sachin + Aaron's May 12 OUT interview anchored on Primary 01, and send for your final approval before any outbound goes out.

Appendix · Full universe (for reference)

Below is the broader universe of angles we considered and the full 4-tier outlet map (152 targets), in case you want to swap in something we set aside.

A1 Outlet Map · 152 Targets, Bottom Up

Sourced via web research on public bylines, About pages, masthead pages, Substack profiles, and personal sites. Full contact paths and email addresses live in the internal research files (not on this site).

Tier 1 · 35 targets

NYC indie & queer voices

Grassroots NYC writers, Substack essayists, queer film podcasters, neighborhood blogs, college papers. Where festival buzz starts.

35
Targets
13
Verified
10
Inferred

Top picks for May window

  • The Yearning (NewFest community partner)
  • Aidan Wharton (Fire Island/Bros credit)
  • Marc Zinaman (NYC queer + body)
  • W42ST (Hell's Kitchen)
  • Hell Gate (NYC critic-circle weight)
Tier 2 · 35 targets

Festival critic circuit

Critics who attend TIFF, NewFest, OutFest, Frameline, Inside Out, Palm Springs. Their coverage signals legitimacy to programmers.

35
Targets
14
Verified
22
Inferred

Top picks for May window

  • Murtada Elfadl (NewFest programmer + Variety critic)
  • Drew Burnett Gregory (sets queer Twitter TIFF agenda)
  • Pat Mullen (Inside Out preview cycle)
  • Chris Azzopardi (Q Syndicate multiplier)
  • Robert Daniels (RogerEbert)
Tier 3 · 47 targets

Mid-tier LGBTQ+ + indie film mags

Indie film magazines, mid-tier queer press, theater crossover, Atlanta press, indie podcasts, body-pos and queer-Asian press.

47
Targets
12+
Verified
11
Podcast hosts

Quick wins (verified inboxes)

  • Hammer to Nail (Don R. Lewis)
  • Slate (Forrest Wickman)
  • Vox (Constance Grady)
  • Pride Source (Chris Azzopardi)
  • Esquire AAPI (Sirena He) for Sachin angle
Tier 4 · 55 targets

Major trades + major LGBTQ+

Variety, Deadline, THR, IndieWire industry, Screen Daily, NYT, New Yorker, Vulture, LA Times, Out, Advocate, them., NPR, Guardian/BBC.

55
Targets
11
Verified senior
12
Stale flagged

Hold for Aug–Oct festival run wave

  • Variety (Marc Malkin existing + Clayton Davis)
  • NYT (Manohla Dargis verified)
  • New Yorker (Justin Chang)
  • Anne Thompson (IndieWire industry)
  • Bilge Ebiri (Vulture chief film critic)

A2 Angles We Considered and Set Aside

If you want to swap in something we set aside, here's the menu and our reasoning for each one.

Retired in v4 · claim doesn't survive a fact-check

"First husky gay leading man in 26 years"

v3's Primary 03. Elle and Cameron flagged "Things Like This" independently as a recent comp. The "first in 26 years" claim doesn't hold up if a writer Googles for thirty seconds. Body politics still rides underneath Primary 02 ("wasn't being cast in love stories") rather than as a leading-claim headline. We don't talk down peer films anywhere — privately or publicly.

Set aside · therapy-adjacent

"Love story between Nick and Nick"

Strong premise, weak frame. The "Nick and Nick" line risked reading as therapy-speak and letting critics dismiss it as a "self-love journey" pitch. Replaced with "He got the dream. The dream made him a secret." Same emotional payload, no therapy-speak.

Set aside · generic dressed as specific

"What happens after you get him"

The "post-kiss structural inversion" framing was editor-speak, not reader-speak. Half of literary fiction does this. The specific hook (the shame of being a secret) got buried inside the structural language. Folded into Primary 01.

Set aside · trend-chasing

Anti-AI Indie

"The romcom that hired a human for every job." Pitch language risks reading defensive instead of affirmative. Could resurface later as a sub-beat in a Filmmaker Magazine profile if it comes up organically.

Set aside · manufactured

Romance As Resistance

The political angle. Real cultural backdrop, but the pitch language collapses into a PSA. We let the existence of the film be its own argument.

Set aside · trend-chasing

TikTok-First Casting

The Julian Burzynski / Aaron Goldenberg cast-for-reach angle. Dilutes the romcom positioning and invites the "TikTok ruined cinema" backlash frame. Cast social activation still happens, just not as a press angle.

Parked · regional

Atlanta Queer Indie Scene

Real and useful, but geographically narrow. Run as a parallel low-effort lane (Atlanta Magazine, AJC, ArtsATL, Creative Loafing, Georgia Voice). Don't let it eat Wave 1 budget.

Parked · industry-only

Nondependent Indie Economics

Ted Hope's "nondependent" model angle. Genuinely interesting to industry writers, but inside-baseball for general audiences. Folded into Primary 02 as the lived-experience origin story.

Folded · craft hook

"Dream Boyfriend / Worst Critic"

The Cameron Moir / fashion-adjacent culture press hook. Now folded INTO Primary 01 as the natural Cameron-led variant of the secret-keeping dynamic.