In Between · The Gaygency
Pitch Strategy · April 27, 2026
Internal Working Doc · For Elle's review

Ten angles.
152 outlets.
One month to land.

We pulled apart the script materials, the investor deck, the kickoff call transcript, and the actual canon of queer film coverage in 2024 to 2026. Here are ten distinct angles, four of them recommended as primary, and a four-tier outlet map of 152 verified or inferred targets to pitch them to. The goal is festival programmer awareness ahead of the May 8 TIFF window — and a press footprint that travels with the film through October.

Angles
10 (4 primary)
Outlets sourced
152 across 4 tiers
Lead deadline
May 8 TIFF
Monthly cap
15 emails / 20 targets

How to read this deck

  1. Start with the angles. Each one says what the pitch actually is, why a writer would publish it, three sample headlines, the lead spokesperson, and what could go wrong. Tell us which 2 of the 4 PRIMARY angles you want us to lead with for the May 8 wave.
  2. Then the outlet map. Four tiers, bottom up. Tier 1 is grassroots NYC. Tier 2 is the festival critic circuit. Tier 3 is mid-tier LGBTQ+ press and indie film magazines. Tier 4 is major trades and major LGBTQ+ outlets. Each tier shows top picks. Full target lists with contact paths live in the internal research files (not on this site).
  3. Then the sequencing. When we send what, in what order, and against which calendar moments.
  4. Then the spokesperson routing. Which of the five locked spokespeople goes to which angle, and which pairings work best.
  5. End on the questions for you. Five things we need from you before the first email goes out.

01 The Angles

Four primary, six alternate. Primary angles carry the broadest legs across outlets; alternates are best deployed for specific writers, beats, or follow-up waves.

01
Primary · Master Positioning

"The Romcom Where the Villain Is You"

Most gay love stories blame society, the family, the love interest, or the closet. In Between is the rare gay romcom that says the obstacle to the love story is the protagonist's own self-rejection — and asks whether you can fall in love with someone before you've made peace with the fact that you exist.

Why it lands now: The post-Love, Simon coming-out template is exhausted. Audiences and critics have been asking out loud what comes after the "we exist" movie. In Between offers an answer. That clean inversion is what essayists love because it gives them something to argue with.
Sample headlines
  • "Finally, a Gay Romcom Where the Villain Is You"
  • "The Anti-Love-Simon: A Queer Romcom About the Person You're Most Afraid To Be Seen By"
  • "What If the Person Rejecting You Was Yourself?"
Lead voice
Nicholas Molencupp · this is his lived story
Best outlets
Tier 1: Aidan Wharton, Coleman Spilde, Marya Gates, Kyle Turner Tier 2: Reverse Shot, Bright Wall/Dark Room, Robert Daniels (RogerEbert) Tier 3: Slate, Vulture (Bilge Ebiri), Vox Tier 4: New Yorker (Justin Chang), NYT (Manohla Dargis), THR (David Rooney)
Risk to watchSome writers will reach for "self-love movie" clichés. Pitch language must lead with the romcom hook (British boyfriend treats Nick as a secret) and let the theme land underneath. Never lead with the theme.
02
Primary · Representation

"Bigger Gay Men Don't Get the Love Story. This Romcom Changes That."

A "husky" gay man has not been the romantic protagonist of a wide-release gay romcom since Big Eden in 2000. In Between makes the bigger gay leading man the camera's subject, not the camera's joke — and makes the love story about him, not around him.

Why it lands now: Body-image discourse in the queer community is sharper than it has been in years. Aubrey Gordon's Maintenance Phase has reframed how mainstream press talks about fat bodies. There is a real, evidence-based gap in the canon, and a journalist can write it without reaching.
Sample headlines
  • "The Husky Gay Romcom Hollywood Forgot To Make"
  • "Bigger Gay Men Got the Sidekick Role for 25 Years. 'In Between' Hands Them the Whole Story."
  • "Why It Took 26 Years for Another 'Big Eden'"
Lead voice
Nicholas + Krystal as paired voice (Nicholas on lived experience, Krystal on the producer-side decision to greenlight a story Hollywood wouldn't)
Best outlets
Tier 1: Marc Zinaman, Greg Herren, body-acceptance Substacks Tier 2: Drew Burnett Gregory's Substack, Tre'vell Anderson (FANTI) Tier 3: Aubrey Gordon, Da'Shaun Harrison, Tagg, Pride Source (Azzopardi) Tier 4: Out (Daniel Reynolds, Tracy E. Gilchrist), Advocate (Christopher Wiggins), them. (Fran Tirado)
Risk to watchThis angle can collapse into "body positivity movie" framing. The film is a romcom, not a PSA. Pitch language must keep "romcom" first and "body" descriptive, not thematic.
03
Primary · Theater Crossover

"Broadway Goes Indie: The 'Hamilton' Producer Backing a Queer Romcom"

Krystal Joy Brown stars in the Merrily We Roll Along live capture premiering on Netflix December 5. While that film opens, her own producing project — a queer indie romcom about self-acceptance — is making its festival run. This is the Broadway-to-indie pipeline that nobody's mapped yet.

Why it lands now: Krystal has a gigantic, dated, public moment landing in December. Theater press, Broadway-adjacent newsletters, and Sondheim coverage will all have a Krystal angle teed up. We piggyback on that. Theater writers love a "what theater stars do off-book" story. Film writers love a "what's it like producing your first feature" story. Same person, two desks, one story.
Sample headlines
  • "Hamilton's Krystal Joy Brown Is Producing a Queer Indie Romcom — And It's Personal"
  • "Inside the Broadway-to-Indie Film Pipeline No One's Talking About"
  • "From 'Merrily' to a Queer Romcom: Krystal Joy Brown's Other 2026 Premiere"
Lead voice
Krystal Joy Brown (primary), Christian DeMarais as supporting (NYU Grad Acting, The Public, theater-to-indie credibility)
Best outlets
Tier 3: Playbill (Logan Culwell-Block, Diep Tran), TheaterMania, NewYorkTheater.me, American Theatre Tier 4: NYT theater desk freelancers, Vulture theater (Sara Holdren), New Yorker (Vinson Cunningham), Variety theater (Gordon Cox, Rebecca Rubin) Tier 1: Las Culturistas if a warm intro materializes (Krystal-via-Broadway)
Risk to watchConfirm Krystal's availability for theater press; her Merrily promo cycle in November/December will be heavy. This angle is most valuable Nov–Dec; for the May 8 TIFF window, lead with Angles 1, 2, and 4.
04
Primary · Industry / Craft

"The Anti-AI Indie: A Queer Romcom Made By People, On Purpose"

In a year when Hollywood is gutting creative jobs to AI, In Between hired a human for every creative seat — every writer, every actor, every editor, every composer. The film's medium is its message: human stories, made by humans, for humans.

Why it lands now: Post-WGA strike, post-SAG strike, with studios announcing AI partnerships every month, there is a real and ongoing hunger for stories about the human side of independent film. Film magazines and tech-meets-culture writers are actively publishing this beat.
Sample headlines
  • "The Indie Romcom That Hired a Human for Every Job — On Purpose"
  • "Made By People: The Anti-AI Manifesto Hidden in a Queer Romcom"
  • "What 'Human-Led Film' Looks Like in 2026"
Lead voice
Elle Army (producer-side decision) + Juli-Ann De Barros (co-director, BFA + Georgia Film Academy — embodies the human-craft thesis)
Best outlets
Tier 3: Filmmaker Magazine (Scott Macaulay), MovieMaker, Hammer to Nail, Cineaste, Vox (Constance Grady), Slate (Sam Adams) Tier 4: IndieWire (Anne Thompson), Variety (Jazz Tangcay craft, Brent Lang business), THR craft beat Tier 2 podcasts: The Big Picture (Sean Fennessey), Filmspotting (Adam Kempenaar)
Risk to watchThis angle can read defensive ("we're not using AI") instead of affirmative ("we built a human practice"). Pitch language must be about what the film IS, not what it isn't. Frame it as a craft story.
05
Alternate · Industry economics

"Nondependent: How Indie Films Get Made in 2026"

Ted Hope coined "nondependent" at Sundance 2026 for a new model of indie filmmaking — self-funded, audience-built before distribution, creator-owned. In Between is exactly that. They Indiegogo'd, leafleted gay bars to fundraise, and are building an audience email list before festival selection so they can prove demand to distributors directly.

Why it lands now: Industry writers are looking for the case study that explains where indie film is going. In Between is a tidy, real, on-the-ground example.
Sample headlines
  • "What 'Nondependent' Indie Film Looks Like — In Practice"
  • "Selling a Movie Before Anyone's Selling It"
  • "The Indie Romcom That's Trying To Prove Distribution Is Optional"
Lead voice
Cameron Moir + Elle Army as paired producer voice
Best outlets
Tier 3: Filmmaker, MovieMaker, Indie Film Hustle (Alex Ferrari), Hammer to Nail Tier 4: IndieWire (Anne Thompson), Variety (Brent Lang), Deadline (Andreas Wiseman) Tier 2: Filmspotting indie-economics episodes, Awards Chatter (Scott Feinberg)
Risk to watchInside-baseball for general audiences. Reserve for Tier 3 / Tier 4 industry trade outlets, not for community press.
06
Alternate · Political (soft)

"Romance As Resistance"

In an administration actively rolling back LGBTQ+ protections, the smallest political act is also the most stubborn — falling in love and laughing about it on screen. In Between is not a political movie, but the act of making it is.

Why it lands now: The 2025 to 2026 federal rollback creates the cultural backdrop. Queer outlets are publishing the "resistance media" beat constantly. We don't make the film a manifesto; we let the existence of the film be the argument.
Sample headlines
  • "Why a Queer Romcom Feels Radical Right Now"
  • "The Quiet Defiance of Falling In Love On Camera"
  • "Romance Is the Refusal They Don't Expect"
Lead voice
Cameron Moir or Elle Army (producer voices). Hold Nicholas's voice for the personal-story angles.
Best outlets
Tier 4: Advocate (Christopher Wiggins — does this beat well), Out (Daniel Reynolds), them. (Fran Tirado, James Factora) Tier 3: Slate Outward, Salon, The Cut Tier 2: Pride Source / Q Syndicate (Chris Azzopardi syndicates to all regional papers), Bay Area Reporter, Washington Blade
Risk to watchPoliticized angles can polarize Meta-platform delivery. Use this for editorial press, not for the paid Meta creative variants.
07
Alternate · Mental Health (Trevor pillar)

"A Romcom That Knows What's Going On In Your Head At 3 A.M."

In Between treats mental health like a real thing inside the love story, not as the love story's punishment. Nick deals with depression and intrusive thoughts on the way to falling in love — not to ennoble him, not to make him tragic, just because that's what's actually happening.

Why it lands now: "Mental health movie" has become a marketing genre. In Between gets to be the rare romcom that takes mental health seriously without being a "mental health movie." That distinction is the whole pitch.
Sample headlines
  • "A Gay Romcom That Knows What's Going On In Your Head At 3 A.M."
  • "What Happens When You Try To Date Through Your Depression"
  • "Falling in Love While Also Trying To Believe You Deserve It"
Lead voice
Nicholas Molencupp · this is his story to tell
Best outlets
Tier 3: Aubrey Gordon's network (Maintenance Phase), Trevor Project communications partners, Crisis Text Line Tier 4: them., Advocate, Out Tier 1: queer-mental-health niche newsletters, Drew Burnett Gregory Substack
Pre-requisiteTrevor Project conversation must be in motion before this angle goes out. Once a percentage-of-proceeds tie-in is confirmed, this becomes the "actionable" angle Krystal asked for on the kickoff call. Pitch language and any landing-page content must include Trevor Project / Crisis Text Line resources.
08
Alternate · Romcom Pairing

"When Your Dream Boyfriend Becomes Your Worst Critic"

Beau is the British Adonis Nick has been told to want — and the moment he gets him, Beau starts treating him as a shameful secret. The film's emotional core is the specific, devastating experience of being wanted in private and refused in public by the person you most wanted to be seen with.

Why it lands now: This is a romcom-craft angle for outlets that love a juicy character pairing. It also travels well to fashion-adjacent culture press because Cameron Moir is in the MARNI FW25 campaign with Natasha Lyonne and is a recognizable face on the gay British model circuit.
Sample headlines
  • "When Your Dream Boyfriend Becomes Your Worst Critic"
  • "The Romcom About Being Wanted In Private and Refused In Public"
  • "What Happens After You Get the British Boyfriend"
Lead voice
Cameron Moir + Nicholas Molencupp paired (the dynamic IS the pitch)
Best outlets
Tier 4: GQ (US + UK), Esquire culture, Vanity Fair, Town & Country Tier 3: them. (fashion-aware), Out (talent profile beat) Tier 2: Substack culture writers in fashion-and-film overlap (Hunter Harris, Coleman Spilde)
Risk to watchThis can collapse into a "fat guy chases hot guy" frame that we explicitly do not want. Pitch language must keep both characters at equal weight; the story is about the dynamic between them, not the chase.
09
Alternate · Cast / Cultural Reach

"The Indie Romcom That Cast TikTok First"

Julian Burzynski (3M TikTok), Aaron Goldenberg (1.1M TikTok), and Nicole Sky are not stunt-cast; they are working actors whose audiences came with them. In Between built its cast for cultural reach, not just craft credits — and the result is a queer indie that has a built-in distribution channel before it's even premiered.

Why it lands now: Industry writers are watching how indies are using social-native talent. This is a pure 2026 phenomenon (Bowen Yang in Fire Island was the early version; this is the next iteration).
Sample headlines
  • "The Indie Romcom That Cast TikTok First"
  • "What Happens When 4 Million Followers Walk Onto Your Indie Set"
  • "The New Cast Strategy: Audience Comes Before Resume"
Lead voice
Krystal Joy Brown + Cameron Moir as paired producer voice
Best outlets
Tier 4: Vulture (E. Alex Jung, Rachel Handler), The Cut, NY Mag, Rolling Stone (Brittany Spanos), GQ Tier 4 industry: Variety (Jazz Tangcay craft, Brent Lang business), IndieWire (Anne Thompson) Tier 2: NPR Pop Culture Happy Hour (Linda Holmes), Talk Easy (Sam Fragoso)
Risk to watchSome writers will use this as a "TikTok ruined cinema" angle. Frame as "audience-first indie filmmaking," not "we cast for followers." The talent itself has to carry the angle.
10
Alternate · Geography

"The Atlanta Queer Indie Scene Hollywood Doesn't Talk About"

The In Between team is Atlanta-based — Nicholas, Juli-Ann, half the cast, Eric Cappuccio. Atlanta has been a tax-credit production city for years; what's emerging now is a queer indie creative scene that lives there year-round, makes its own work, and isn't a Hollywood satellite.

Why it lands now: Atlanta press loves a "we're a real city" angle. Soft-grassroots pitch with built-in regional pickup. It's also a way to get into press the bigger publications miss.
Sample headlines
  • "Atlanta's Quiet Queer Indie Film Scene"
  • "Made in Atlanta, On Purpose: A Queer Romcom That Couldn't Have Been Made In LA"
  • "Why Atlanta Is The Queer Indie City Nobody's Mapped Yet"
Lead voice
Juli-Ann De Barros (co-director, Atlanta-rooted) + Nicholas
Best outlets
Tier 3: Atlanta Magazine, AJC arts (Donald Harrison / Shane Harrison desk), ArtsATL, Creative Loafing, Georgia Voice / Rough Draft Atlanta
Risk to watchGeographically narrow. Best deployed in parallel with bigger angles; doesn't replace them.

02 Recommended Primary Stack for May 8 TIFF Window

If we're picking two angles to lead with for the next 30 days, this is what we recommend. Hold the others for sequenced waves.

1

Angle 01 · Master positioning

"The Romcom Where the Villain Is You" is the angle every other angle stems from. Use it for the core press release, Substack essayists, and long-form essay outlets across all four tiers.

2

Angle 02 · Community wave

"Bigger Gay Men Don't Get the Love Story" as the second pitch wave for body-image, LGBTQ+ representation, and Tier 3 outlets. This is the angle that gets community shares.

3

Angle 04 · Industry trade

"The Anti-AI Indie" as the industry-trade pitch. This is what gets Filmmaker, MovieMaker, IndieWire industry desk, and Hammer to Nail to take a meeting.

Hold Angle 03 (Krystal / Broadway) for the November/December push when Merrily Netflix premieres. Hold Angle 07 (mental health) until Trevor Project is in motion. Use Angles 5, 6, 8, 9, and 10 as outlet-specific variants when a writer's beat fits.

03 The Outlet Map · 152 Targets, Bottom Up

Sourced via web research on public bylines, About pages, masthead pages, Substack profiles, and personal sites. Full contact paths and email addresses live in the internal research files (not on this site).

Tier 1

NYC indie & queer voices

Grassroots NYC writers, Substack essayists, queer film podcasters, neighborhood blogs, college papers. The bottom-up tier. Where festival buzz starts.

35
Targets
13
Verified emails
10
Inferred emails
12
DM/contact-form fallback

Substack essayists & queer film writers

  • Aidan Wharton · Gay Buffet (was in Fire Island AND Bros — strongest warm-intro angle on the list)
  • Coleman Spilde · Salon / Top Shelf, Low Brow Substack (Brooklyn)
  • Marya Gates · Cool People Have Feelings, Too (NYC rep-theater curator)
  • Hunter Harris · Hung Up (85K+ subs, ex-Vulture)
  • Kyle Turner · author of The Queer Film Guide (Brooklyn-based, definitive queer-canon authority)
  • Louis Peitzman · High Drama (theater + film, NYT/Vulture/Time)
  • Marc Zinaman · Queer Happened Here: NYC (NYC queer history authority)
  • Meg Steinfeld-Heim & Ali Romig · The Yearning Brooklyn (NewFest community partner)
  • John Russell · Johnny Writes… (gay-canon rewatch series)
  • Greg Herren (body-image-meets-gay-life essayist)
  • Trish Bendix · LIT FEMME (queer-women angle)
  • Saeed Jones · Werk-In-Progress (Pulitzer finalist long-shot)

NYC queer culture podcasts

  • Joe Reid + Chris Feil · This Had Oscar Buzz (NY-based gay critics)
  • Sundays at Café Tabac · Wanda Acosta + Karen Song
  • Ashley Gavin · We're Having Gay Sex (500K+ TikTok)
  • Matt Rogers + Bowen Yang · Las Culturistas (long shot, Krystal angle)
  • Daniel Gray · Indie Solo (interviews queer indie producers)

NYC neighborhood + queer press

  • W42ST (Hell's Kitchen, queer-focused weekly newsletter)
  • Hell Gate NYC (worker-owned indie outlet, culture editor Julianne Escobedo Shepherd)
  • Brooklyn Paper, Greenpointers, Bushwick Daily (Brooklyn neighborhood)
  • GO Magazine, Tagg Magazine, Gay City News (NYC queer)

NYC student arts press

  • Washington Square News (NYU) · Dani Biondi, Skylar Boilard, Julia Kim, Chantal Mann
  • Columbia Spectator · Gabi Fabozzi (Deputy A&C Editor), Aamina Mughal, Spectrum desk
Top picks for May window The Yearning (NewFest community partner — must know pre-NewFest38), Aidan Wharton (Fire Island/Bros credit), Marc Zinaman (NYC queer + body-image), W42ST (Hell's Kitchen demo), Hell Gate (NYC critic-circle weight)
Tier 2

Festival critic circuit

Critics, reporters, and programmers' favorite trade writers who actually attend and review films at TIFF, NewFest, OutFest, Frameline, Inside Out, Palm Springs. Their coverage signals legitimacy to programmers and distributors.

35
Targets
14
Verified emails
22
Inferred emails
0
No path

TIFF / festival reporters

  • David Ehrlich · IndieWire chief critic
  • Ryan Lattanzio · IndieWire (gates TIFF coverage)
  • Kate Erbland · IndieWire
  • Carlos Aguilar · IndieWire / NYT / LA Times freelance
  • Tomris Laffly · Variety / RogerEbert / Time / Filmmaker
  • Brian Tallerico · RogerEbert.com
  • Robert Daniels · RogerEbert / NYT / Reverse Shot
  • Glenn Kenny · RogerEbert / NYT
  • Damon Wise · Deadline international/festival
  • Sasha Stone · Awards Daily
  • Erik Anderson, Sophia Ciminello, Ryan McQuade · AwardsWatch
  • Todd Brown · ScreenAnarchy

NewFest + NYC festival circuit

  • Murtada Elfadl · NewFest Senior Programmer AND Variety film critic (single highest-leverage contact on the list)
  • Bilge Ebiri · Vulture / NY Mag chief film critic
  • Alison Willmore · Vulture / NY Mag
  • Alissa Wilkinson · NYT
  • James Factora · them.
  • Brian Braiker · Brooklyn Magazine
  • Daniella Shreir · Another Gaze

OutFest / Frameline / Inside Out coverage

  • Mick LaSalle · San Francisco Chronicle
  • Jim Provenzano · Bay Area Reporter
  • Pat Mullen · POV Magazine + Xtra (Inside Out preview cycle)
  • Peter Howell · Toronto Star
  • Glenn Sumi · Toronto Star (formerly NOW Magazine)
  • Norm Wilner · NOW Toronto Substack
  • Radheyan Simonpillai · CTV + freelance

Regional LGBTQ+ press

  • Jeremy Rodriguez · Philadelphia Gay News
  • Gary M. Kramer · Philadelphia Gay News + Gay City News
  • Bay Windows arts desk · Boston
  • Matt Minton, Joey DiGuglielmo · Washington Blade
  • Chris Azzopardi · Q Syndicate (one pitch wires to all regional LGBTQ papers — biggest single multiplier)
Top picks for May window Murtada Elfadl (NewFest programmer + Variety critic, double-purpose), Drew Burnett Gregory (sets queer Twitter TIFF agenda), Ryan Lattanzio (IndieWire TIFF gatekeeper), Pat Mullen (Inside Out preview cycle), Chris Azzopardi (Q Syndicate multiplier)
Tier 3

Mid-tier LGBTQ+ + indie film mags

Independent film magazines, mid-tier queer press, theater/Broadway crossover, culture long-form, Atlanta press, indie podcasts, body-positivity press, queer-Asian press. Carries weight without the trade gatekeeping.

47
Targets
12+
Verified inboxes
7
Atlanta-specific
11
Podcast hosts

Indie film magazines

  • Scott Macaulay · Filmmaker Magazine (editor)
  • Tim Molloy · MovieMaker Magazine
  • Don R. Lewis · Hammer to Nail (verified inbox, fast quick-win)
  • Mike Williams · Sight & Sound (BFI)
  • Devika Girish · Film Comment (relationship + podcast pitch)
  • Michael Koresky · Reverse Shot
  • Cynthia Lucia · Cineaste
  • Brian Tallerico, Monica Castillo · RogerEbert.com
  • Alex Ferrari · Indie Film Hustle podcast

Theater + Broadway crossover (Krystal angle)

  • Diep Tran, Logan Culwell-Block · Playbill
  • Robert Diamond · BroadwayWorld
  • David Gordon · TheaterMania
  • Rob Weinert-Kendt, Kelundra Smith (Atlanta) · American Theatre
  • Jonathan Mandell · NewYorkTheater.me
  • Chris Peterson · OnStage Blog

Atlanta press

  • Cinqué Hicks, Shane Harrison (also AJC), Denise K. James · ArtsATL
  • Tony Paris · Creative Loafing Atlanta
  • Atlanta Magazine editorial
  • Georgia Voice / Rough Draft Atlanta (queer Atlanta paper)

Podcasts that review film

  • Adam Kempenaar + Josh Larsen · Filmspotting
  • Sean Fennessey + Amanda Dobbins · The Big Picture (The Ringer)
  • Tasha Robinson team · The Next Picture Show
  • Brian Saur + Elric Kane · Pure Cinema (New Beverly)
  • Karina Longworth · You Must Remember This (verified inbox)
  • Sam Fragoso · Talk Easy
  • Scott Feinberg · Awards Chatter
  • Tre'vell Anderson · FANTI / What A Day
  • Bryan Lowder · Slate Outward LGBTQ podcast

Body-positivity / fat studies

  • Aubrey Gordon · Maintenance Phase
  • Da'Shaun Harrison
  • Virgie Tovar
  • Lindy West

Mid-tier LGBTQ+ + culture long-form

  • Forrest Wickman, Sam Adams · Slate
  • Constance Grady, Alex Abad-Santos · Vox
  • Joe Reid (Senior Writer, Vulture)
  • The Cut pitch inbox; GQ Frazier Tharpe; Esquire Sirena He (AAPI angle for Sachin)
  • Adam Rathe · Town & Country

Queer Asian press (Sachin Bhatt angle)

  • Hyphen Magazine (2 contacts)
  • NextShark, AsAmNews, Asian American Press
Quick wins (verified inboxes + clear topical fit) Hammer to Nail (Don R. Lewis), Slate (Forrest Wickman), Film Comment (Devika Girish), Playbill (Diep Tran + Logan Culwell-Block), Pride Source (Chris Azzopardi), Esquire AAPI (Sirena He), Vox (Constance Grady), Creative Loafing Atlanta (Tony Paris), ArtsATL/AJC (Shane Harrison — two outlets, one pitch)
Tier 4

Major trades + major LGBTQ+

Variety, Deadline, Hollywood Reporter, IndieWire industry, Screen International, NYT, New Yorker, Vulture, LA Times, Rolling Stone, Out, Advocate, them., NPR, Guardian/BBC. Beyond the existing one-name-per-outlet starter list.

55
Targets
11
Verified senior inboxes
19
Outlet groups
12
Stale contacts flagged

Trades · deeper bench

  • Variety: Clayton Davis (awards), Jazz Tangcay (craft, verified), Anna Marie de la Fuente, Naman Ramachandran, Owen Gleiberman, theater desk Gordon Cox + Rebecca Rubin (Krystal angle)
  • Deadline: Pete Hammond, Anthony D'Alessandro, Matt Grobar (verified, indie/festival), Andreas Wiseman (international/sales)
  • The Hollywood Reporter: David Rooney (chief critic, queer-friendly), Lovia Gyarkye, Jordan Mintzer (festival), Rebecca Sun (verified, diversity desk), Scott Roxborough (TIFF)
  • IndieWire: David Ehrlich (verified), Anne Thompson (industry/sales), Christian Zilko (festival), Brian Welk
  • Screen International: Tim Grierson, Wendy Mitchell, Jeremy Kay (Americas), Ben Dalton, Wendy Ide, Matt Mueller

NYT · multiple desks

  • Manohla Dargis (chief film critic, verified)
  • Beatrice Loayza (queer indie reviews)
  • Kyle Buchanan (Carpetbagger awards)
  • Guy Trebay (Style/queer culture)
  • Maya Phillips, Laura Collins-Hughes (theater for KJB angle)

New Yorker / NY Mag / Vulture

  • Justin Chang (chief film critic)
  • Doreen St. Félix (TV/film)
  • Vinson Cunningham (theater)
  • Bilge Ebiri, Alison Willmore, Angelica Jade Bastién, Roxana Hadadi (Vulture critics)
  • E. Alex Jung, Rachel Handler (NY Mag culture features)
  • Sara Holdren (Vulture theater)

LA Times, Rolling Stone, AP, Atlantic

  • Glenn Whipp (LAT awards), Carlos Aguilar (LAT/IndieWire freelance)
  • David Fear, K. Austin Collins, Brittany Spanos · Rolling Stone
  • Jake Coyle · AP Entertainment (verified)
  • Spencer Kornhaber · The Atlantic (verified)

Major LGBTQ+ · second contacts

  • Out: Daniel Reynolds (entertainment), Tracy E. Gilchrist
  • Advocate: John Casey
  • them. (now Equalpride): Fran Tirado (new EIC), James Factora, Samantha Allen
  • Autostraddle: Kayla Kumari Upadhyaya
  • Mey Rude (freelance, verified personal)

UK · Guardian / BBC / Independent / Attitude

  • Peter Bradshaw, Caspar Salmon, Catherine Shoard (verified), Steve Rose · Guardian
  • Hugh Montgomery, Caryn James · BBC Culture
  • Attitude Magazine UK (queer outlet)

NPR, Slate

  • Linda Holmes · Pop Culture Happy Hour
  • Aisha Harris (queer indie)
  • Glen Weldon · NPR
Stale contacts flagged (don't pitch) Drew Burnett Gregory (laid off from For Them early 2026), Carmen Phillips (left Autostraddle 2024), Lena Wilson (left NYT 2023), Helen Shaw (left New Yorker 2025), Jesse Green (reassigned from NYT theater 2025), Naveen Kumar (now Wash Post Theater Critic — pitch him there, not Esquire/GQ), Eric Kohn (left IndieWire 2021), Tambay Obenson (now Akoroko), EJ Dickson (now WIRED), Fionnuala Halligan (left Screen Daily for Red Sea). Full list with current placement in the internal research file.

04 Sequencing · Four Waves

Per signed SOW: 20 press targets and 15 outreach emails per month. We sequence so the May 8 wave hits the highest-leverage contacts first and the rest stack against the festival calendar.

Wave 1 · May 1–7

Pre-deadline urgency

The Yearning (NewFest community partner), Aidan Wharton (Fire Island/Bros credit), Murtada Elfadl (NewFest programmer + Variety critic — double purpose), Marc Zinaman, NewFest submission by May 5, plus the existing Tier 4 contacts already on Elle's starter list.

Wave 2 · May 8–17

Post-submission surge

Hunter Harris (Hung Up), Joe Reid + Chris Feil, Coleman Spilde, W42ST (Hell's Kitchen), Hell Gate, Brooklyn Paper, Drew Burnett Gregory's Substack. Tier 1 grassroots + Tier 2 critic-circle.

Wave 3 · June

Industry trade + body-pos

Filmmaker, MovieMaker, Hammer to Nail, Anne Thompson at IndieWire (Anti-AI angle). Aubrey Gordon, Da'Shaun Harrison, Tagg, Pride Source/Q Syndicate (body-pos angle).

Wave 4 · Aug–Oct

Festival run + Krystal pivot

Festival critic circle (Tier 2) reactivates around TIFF/NewFest dates. Theater press for Krystal angle as Merrily Netflix promo cycle starts in November. NYU + Columbia student arts press once school resumes.

05 Spokesperson Routing

Five locked spokespeople (per signed SOW). Each angle has a recommended lead. We don't route press to anyone outside this list.

Nicholas Molencupp
Writer / Director / Lead
  • Angle 01 (lead — lived story)
  • Angle 02 (paired with Krystal)
  • Angle 07 (mental health)
  • Angle 08 (paired with Cameron)
  • Angle 10 (Atlanta)
Krystal Joy Brown
Executive Producer
  • Angle 03 (lead — Hamilton/Merrily)
  • Angle 02 (paired with Nicholas)
  • Angle 09 (paired with Cameron)
Cameron Moir
Producer / Actor (Beau)
  • Angle 08 (lead — love-interest dynamic)
  • Angle 09 (paired with Krystal)
  • Angle 05 (industry, paired with Elle)
  • Angle 06 (resistance)
Elle Army
Producer / Actor
  • Angle 04 (lead — anti-AI / production decision)
  • Angle 05 (paired with Cameron)
  • Angle 06 (resistance)
Jay Manuel
Senior Executive Producer
  • Hold for Tier 4 name-recognition outlets only (Variety, THR, Deadline, Out)
  • Pair with Nicholas when used
  • Best for awards-cycle and broader-reach pickups, not the May 8 wave

06 What we need from you

Five answers before the first email goes out. We hold all outreach until you confirm.

Which 2 of the 4 PRIMARY angles do you want us to lead with for the May 8 wave? We recommend Angle 01 + Angle 02; Angle 03 holds for November.
Has Krystal confirmed she's available for Broadway/theater-press interviews in May, or should we hold Angle 03 entirely?
Trevor Project — is anyone on the producing side actively reaching out, or do you want us to draft an intro email so we can start the conversation?
Are there any angles here you do NOT want us to use? (Political framing, body framing, mental health framing — any of these need your sign-off before they go out.)
Are there spokesperson pairings we listed that wouldn't be feasible (calendar conflicts, dynamic concerns, stretch availability)?
Confirm the four-wave sequencing matches your timing instinct, or tell us which wave to compress / pull forward / cut.

Once you lock the answers, we'll refine the two lead angles into a one-page pitch with headline + opening paragraph for each, build the May 1–7 outreach list inside our SOW caps (15 emails / 20 targets), and send everything for your final approval before any outbound goes out.